EXCLUSIVE: The EU loses Round One of Brexit Trade Negotiations
Barnier banged to (human) rights in shocking expose of EU hypocrisy
Barnier lectures UK on European Convention on Human Rights, forgetting EU hasn't signed it
The EU has demanded that any trade deal with the UK be contingent on the UK making a commitment in the new trade treaty to abide by the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR).
On Thursday, the EU’s Chief Negotiator Monsieur Michel Barnier got very exercised about this subject in his long statement in French following the first round of UK-EU trade talks this week.
There’s just one 'leetle, eenzy-weenzy' problem for Monsieur Barnier
Brexit Facts4EU.Org Summary
The European Convention on Human Rights
The UK signed the ECHR in 1950 and ratified it the following year
The EU has still not signed nor ratified it
Above: Details of Council of Europe Treaty No.005 - Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms, commonly known as “The European Convention on Human Rights”
[Source: © Council of Europe, as at Sat 07 Mar 2020.] - click to enlarge
Barnier on “EUman rights”
Below is an excerpt from the statement given by the EU’s Chief Negotiator to the world's press on Thursday.
Brexit Facts4EU.Org Summary
Michel Barnier's summary of first round trade negotiations
© EU Commission
“Ambitious cooperation requires commitments on both sides with regard to the fundamental rights of individuals.
“However, the United Kingdom has informed us that it does not want to make a formal commitment to continue to apply the European Convention on Human Rights. Nor does it want the European Court of Justice to play its full role in the interpretation of European law - and this is particularly serious when it comes to the fundamental rights of individuals.
“If this position is maintained, this would have an immediate and concrete effect on the ambition of our cooperation, which will remain possible on the basis of international conventions, but which cannot be as ambitious as we wish.”
- Michel Barnier, EU Chief Negotiator – Statement after first round talks, Brussels, 05 Mar 2020
Is it really true the EU has not signed nor ratified the “European Convention on Human Rights”?
Bizarrely, yes it’s true.
At the end of Round One of the trade talks with the UK last week, Michel Barnier lectured the UK at great length about human rights, and the need for the UK to include its commitment to the European Convention on Human Rights in the trade treaty.
Brexit Facts4EU.Org Summary
Sadly Mister Barnier seems to have forgotten one very crucial point:
The EU has not signed nor ratified the European Convention on Human Rights
How is this remotely possible?
The EU has a legal obligation – to say nothing of any moral obligation – to sign the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR) as a result of the Lisbon Treaty signed by all EU member countries back in December 2007.
For those politicians such as the Rt Hon Kenneth Clarke MP, who boasted of never having read EU Treaties, they could look this obligation up in Article 6 (2) of the Lisbon Treaty.
As the EU Parliament said:
Does irony ever get more delicious than this?
In a move of such delicious irony we barely know where to start, it was the European Court of Justice that stepped in and prevented the EU from signing the European Convention on Human Rights. It seems that in 2014 the Justices decided that the ECHR might override their powers under the EU Treaties.
Apparently “accession [to the ECHR] was liable to upset the underlying balance of the EU and undermine the autonomy of EU law.”
Since 2014 the EU Commission – of which Michel Barnier is an employee – has repeatedly said that it considers accession to the ECHR to be a priority. Six years later and the EU is still not even close to either signature or ratification. And this is almost 70 years after the UK signed the Convention.
Does the EU have any chance of lifting itself up to UK standards?
In order to move closer to a point where the EU could say it was lifting itself to UK standards, the EU would have to sign and ratify the Convention. For this to happen, the following will be required:-
A renegotiation of the Convention to suit the EU Commission and the EU Court of Justice
Unanimous agreement by the EU Council
Agreement and ratification by all EU Member States
Agreement and ratification by all non-EU states which are party to the Convention
Approval by the EU Parliament
Approval by the Council of Europe
One of the ‘non-EU states’ we refer to above which would need to agree to any changes will be the UK, of course. To remind readers, the UK has been a signatory of the Convention for almost 70 years, since 1951.
The question to Monsieur Barnier must therefore surely be this
“When is the EU going to lift its standards to the level of British standards on human rights?”
Tomorrow we will turn the screw a little more. We will show how the EU27 are seriously underperforming the UK in a crucial area of human rights.
As usual we will use the latest figures from the EU itself, released only days ago.
Finally, please speak English, Mister Barnier
Various members of the Brexit Facts4EU.Org team are fluent in European languages other than English. This is one of the reasons we can bring you news from around the EU in the way we do. We enjoy different languages in the same way we love different European cultures. This is one of the reasons we love Europe but hate the EU, with all the EU's attempts at homogenisation and its clear desire to destroy the identity of individual nations.
When it comes to absolute fundamentals such as the UK-EU trade talks, however, we feel it is simply unacceptable for the EU Commission to publish long statements in a minority language such as French. On Thursday the vast majority of Mr Barnier’s statement after the three days of trade talks was in French.
These talks are important. Everyone across the EU needs to understand what is being said. The EU’s common language is English. Please use it, Mister Barnier.
[ Sources: EU Commission | Council of Europe | EU Parliament | ] Politicians and journalists can contact us for details, as ever.
Brexit Facts4EU.Org, Sat 07 Mar 2020