How many City players would you keep?

[breaker 0]

If you had the chance to sell the lot and start again?

My choices:

Safri, Ashton, McKenzie, Etuhu (for potential), Davenport, Doherty, Shackell, Colin, Wright, Drury, Ward, Green, Rossi Jarvis

[Robbo007 0]

Agree with you, except, i''d get rid of Etuhu and Green, and keep Drury

[Syteanric 1]

Safs, Ashton, Mckenzie, Drury, Gallagher, Doherty, id try and sign Davenport and Wright, Ryan Jarvis, Rossi Jarvis, Hendo, Colin, Brennan

id sell Greeno to generate transfer funds.. the rest can all toddle off

jas :)

[ZLF 333]

 Starting a fresh I think I would only not have are Brennan, Hendo, Flem or Charlie, and the latter two only because they are too old - happy to keep one as a squad filler if cant sign anyone younger.  

The rest I would keep (even Cpn Clapper) as the squad is too small and all can do a job when second choice.  In midfield we need 3 class signings to get some real competition for places and true ability.

I am confident that a new manager would get more from this squad which is not that bad - just lacking in confidence due to tactical incompetence.

Of this seasons loanees?   Lisbie - nah, worse than we already have , Wright, nah no better than Colin or Flem, Marney - maybe would like to see how he went given a run in midfield with Safri,  Robinson, tidy better than we have (thats not much of a compliment!) but not sure how good yet, Etuhu, ditto - although first impressions virge towards a no thanks.   Davenport - yes if we have the cash for him and midfielders - no if its means we cant strengthen the middle of the park.

 

OTBC

[Northern Canary 0]

would have said give Brennan a new contract but after last saturday, im not sure.