Definetly Doherty, McDonald and Lee should be commended. Clingan has done well too - I''d like to say that Carney should have been dropped for Lappin, definetly the better player and out of all the loanees Alan Gow did standout for me - brilliant close ball control although he did have the tendency to run it into trouble a bit. I think the emergency loanees were a good idea, they have done well in some games but it felt like they were just playing to appeal to perhaps other clubs who might be watching rather than giving it all like some of the actual city players.