How does Roeder compare to our previous managers ?

[blahblahblah 2]

How does GRs'' performance sit against those of our previous managers ?  Here is a list of win percentages for every manager since John Bond, as supplied by wikipedia and monkeyed about by me.

Win percentages from John Bond - Now

46.2 Martin O''Neill (Aug - Dec 1995)
.....P26 W12 D9 L5
40.9 Ken Brown (Nov 80 - Nov 87)
.....P367 W150 D93 L124
40.7 Nigel Worthington (Dec 00 - Oct 06)
.....P280 W114 D104 L62
38.9 Dave Stringer (Nov 87 - May 92)
.....P229 W89 D58 L82
38.5 Mike Walker (Jun 93 - Jan 94, Jun 96 - Apr 98)
.....P179 W69 D46 L64
36.2 Peter Grant (Oct 06 - Oct 07)
.....P47 W17 D11 L19
34.5 John Bond (Nov 73 - Oct 80)
.....P340 W105 D114 L121
33.3 Glenn Roeder (Oct 07 - present)
.....P60 W20 D14 L26
32.3 Bruce Rioch (Jun 98 - Mar 00)
.....P93 W30 D31 L32
28.6 Bryan Hamilton (Apr 00 - Dec 00)
.....P35 W10 D10 L15
22.4 John Deehan (Apr 95 - Jul 95)
.....P58 W13 D22 L23

The only manager less successful at winning games than GR who had more time in the post was Bruce Rioch, he had 19 months and 93 games.  Rioch also drew significantly more games, giving him a better points per game record if you assume 3 points for a win.

Points per Game, from John Bond - Now

1.76 Martin O Neill - 26 games
1.59 Nigel Worthington - 280 games
1.48 Ken Brown - 367 games
1.42 Dave Stringer - 229 games
1.41 Mike Walker - 179 games
1.32 Peter Grant - 47 games
1.30 Bruce Rioch - 93 games
1.26 John Bond - 340 games
1.23 Glenn Roeder - 60 games
1.14 Bryan Hamilton - 35 games
1.05 John Deehan - 58 games

 

[steve b 0]

if he stays Glen Roeder will go down as our worst ever manager, he already is in my eyes

[ZLF 271]

ties in nicely with our league position.  No Gary Megson?

When looking at Worthington would like to see Ron Saunders record in comparison as both go the club promoted and relegated.

 

[blahblahblah 2]

Oops, must have missed Megson - he would be at the bottom of the list.

Gary Megson

December, 1995

21 June 1996

32

5

10

17

15.6

[Jonnyboy 0]

Come back Peter all is forgiven...

 

[Bovril 219]

I know people slated him but it just shows what a good job worthy done with his time here, to be second to martin o''neill is no mean feat...particulary when he took us over with the squad he had

[ZLF 271]

[quote user="blahblahblah"]

Oops, must have missed Megson - he would be at the bottom of the list.

Gary Megson

December, 1995

21 June 1996

32

5

10

17

15.6

[/quote]

 

ty blah,  considerably bottom of both piles... can understand why you wanted to forget him!!

[blahblahblah 2]

Rons points per game was 1.42, on the basis of a 3 point win.

Ron Saunders  1 July 1969 16 November 1973 P 221 W 84 D 61 L 76 % 38.0 PPG 1.42
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Norwich_City_F.C.

[blahblahblah 2]

[quote user="ZippersLeftFoot"][quote user="blahblahblah"]

Oops, must have missed Megson - he would be at the bottom of the list.

Gary Megson

December, 1995

21 June 1996

32

5

10

17

15.6

[/quote]

 

ty blah,  considerably bottom of both piles... can understand why you wanted to forget him!!

[/quote]

Absolutely Zipper, immenently forgettable, and yet somehow a Premiership manager now.  He must have learnt something [:)]

 

[Scot-e-dog 34]

These figures are really interesting, especially when you consider Roeder''s first 15 or so games in charge pulled in loads of points.His record since then must be diabolical (Obviously only a point a game this season - worse if you include cup games and a less that 30% win ratio)Conversely, Worthington''s last season and a half were poor, so what must his record have been like before that?

[ZLF 271]

Worthington our sugar and spice manager - when he was good he was very very good,   but when he was bad  he was horrid... 

We need to learn from that - a stable squad where the players knew their roles and were better than their ability in that team.  Compare that to the rapid squad and manager rotation since we got not relegated but promoted.  Do we have enough time to make that work again?

Its nopt about money,  its about team work. 

[Rudolph Hucker 0]

I fully agree with that last comment Zipper and I hadn''t appreciated how seldom we lost games under Worthy.

[alex_ncfc 644]

Roeder has only been in the job a year but is half way on the way to ''achieving'' as many defeats in that tenure as Worthy did in 6 years.