Jump to content
Sign in to follow this  
PhatCanary

Love him or hate him a question about Roeder for you all

Recommended Posts

[quote user="PhatCanary"]

 If Roeder was given the funds,could he get us to the Premier League? 

[/quote]

He would certainly get us good players and assemble a very strong looking team, but would they get enough points on the board? Maybe after a few seasons of trying, although I still think that the playoffs would be our only route to the Prem as I can''t see us ever finding the consistency like Wolves/Birmingham can to be a top two side.

If only Roy Keane would come here!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
[quote user="PhatCanary"]

 If Roeder was given the funds,could he get us to the Premier League? 

[/quote]

Doesn''t really work like that. If Roeder was given the funds that Mark Hughes has been given at Man City then yes, eventually he would. But so would any football manager!

If he was given a respectable amount and no more, then no, I don''t believe he would.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
i do wonder that if he had any money he would sign the same players we have now(ie loan players) only full time. i think we would be around the same position

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
[quote user="venta icenorum"][quote user="PhatCanary"]

 If Roeder was given the funds,could he get us to the Premier League? 

[/quote]

He would certainly get us good players and assemble a very strong looking team, but would they get enough points on the board? Maybe after a few seasons of trying, although I still think that the playoffs would be our only route to the Prem as I can''t see us ever finding the consistency like Wolves/Birmingham can to be a top two side.

If only Roy Keane would come here!

[/quote]

Heaven Forbid Roy Keane coming here - if you think Roeder is irrational, Keane''s far worse!!

I agree that it would take Roeder years to assemble a promotion winning team, I think he''s more of a troubleshooter (saved us from relegation) than a finisher

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
[quote user="PhatCanary"]

 If Roeder was given the funds,could he get us to the Premier League? 

[/quote]He has no man-management skills and is tactically inept so no amount of money would put that right

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
I honestly don''t think he would. I believe he would achieve brief success over a short period, but ultimately would lose the dressing room and thus performances nosedive.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

[quote user="John Boubepo"][quote user="PhatCanary"]

 If Roeder was given the funds,could he get us to the Premier League? 

[/quote]He has no man-management skills and is tactically inept so no amount of money would put that right[/quote]

What that man said.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
No, i honestly believe he wouldnt. With no funds he has attracted decent players but cannot make them play or in Lupoli''s cas wont play him at all!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
[quote user="swindoncanary"]If I was given enough I could get us to the premiership ![/quote]

No seriously you wouldn''t.Your choice of avatar tells me that.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

[quote user="swindoncanary"]If I was given enough I could get us to the premiership ![/quote]

Ok then for the smart arses out there,if he was given the same to spend as the Reading,Birmingham,Wolves and Ipswich managers would he build a team to get promoted?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
[quote user="venta icenorum"][quote user="PhatCanary"]

 If Roeder was given the funds,could he get us to the Premier League? 

[/quote]

He would certainly get us good players and assemble a very strong looking team, but would they get enough points on the board? Maybe after a few seasons of trying, although I still think that the playoffs would be our only route to the Prem as I can''t see us ever finding the consistency like Wolves/Birmingham can to be a top two side.

If only Roy Keane would come here!

[/quote]

 

You really wouldn''t want to know what Roy thinks (privately) about fans.  You really wouldn''t.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

[quote user="Camuldonum"][quote user="venta icenorum"][quote user="PhatCanary"]

 If Roeder was given the funds,could he get us to the Premier League? 

[/quote]

He would certainly get us good players and assemble a very strong looking team, but would they get enough points on the board? Maybe after a few seasons of trying, although I still think that the playoffs would be our only route to the Prem as I can''t see us ever finding the consistency like Wolves/Birmingham can to be a top two side.

If only Roy Keane would come here!

[/quote]

 

You really wouldn''t want to know what Roy thinks (privately) about fans.  You really wouldn''t.

[/quote]

Come on, Camul-toe, tell the truth for once!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
[quote user="shyster"][quote user="Camuldonum"][quote user="venta icenorum"][quote user="PhatCanary"]

 If Roeder was given the funds,could he get us to the Premier League? 

[/quote]

He would certainly get us good players and assemble a very strong looking team, but would they get enough points on the board? Maybe after a few seasons of trying, although I still think that the playoffs would be our only route to the Prem as I can''t see us ever finding the consistency like Wolves/Birmingham can to be a top two side.

If only Roy Keane would come here!

[/quote]

 

You really wouldn''t want to know what Roy thinks (privately) about fans.  You really wouldn''t.

[/quote]


Come on, Camul-toe, tell the truth for once!
[/quote]

Fugg off cameltoe......

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
[quote user="Camuldonum"][quote user="venta icenorum"][quote user="PhatCanary"]

 If Roeder was given the funds,could he get us to the Premier League? 

[/quote]

He would certainly get us good players and assemble a very strong looking team, but would they get enough points on the board? Maybe after a few seasons of trying, although I still think that the playoffs would be our only route to the Prem as I can''t see us ever finding the consistency like Wolves/Birmingham can to be a top two side.

If only Roy Keane would come here!

[/quote]

You really wouldn''t want to know what Roy thinks (privately) about fans.  You really wouldn''t.

[/quote]

It''s not so private Cam. I''ve heard Keane interviews at least four times this season already when, referring to the fans he said, "If they don''t like it then stuff them" and variations along those lines.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
[quote user="shyster"][quote user="Camuldonum"][quote user="venta icenorum"][quote user="PhatCanary"]

 If Roeder was given the funds,could he get us to the Premier League? 

[/quote]

He would certainly get us good players and assemble a very strong looking team, but would they get enough points on the board? Maybe after a few seasons of trying, although I still think that the playoffs would be our only route to the Prem as I can''t see us ever finding the consistency like Wolves/Birmingham can to be a top two side.

If only Roy Keane would come here!

[/quote]

 

You really wouldn''t want to know what Roy thinks (privately) about fans.  You really wouldn''t.

[/quote]


Come on, Camul-toe, tell the truth for once!
[/quote]

 

Okay, I don''t think you have the resources to be a Premier League club in the current set up.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
[quote user="Camuldonum"][quote user="shyster"][quote user="Camuldonum"][quote user="venta icenorum"][quote user="PhatCanary"]

 If Roeder was given the funds,could he get us to the Premier League? 

[/quote]

He would certainly get us good players and assemble a very strong looking team, but would they get enough points on the board? Maybe after a few seasons of trying, although I still think that the playoffs would be our only route to the Prem as I can''t see us ever finding the consistency like Wolves/Birmingham can to be a top two side.

If only Roy Keane would come here!

[/quote]

 

You really wouldn''t want to know what Roy thinks (privately) about fans.  You really wouldn''t.

[/quote]


Come on, Camul-toe, tell the truth for once!
[/quote]

 

Okay, I don''t think you have the resources to be a Premier League club in the current set up.

[/quote]

PS: Mr Keane thinks that many football supporters are "not very bright and mostly couldn''t hold their place in a park side but they always seem to know what someone else should do.  Actually most of them are ******* thicker than the walls of Newcastle Cathedral."

That is not suggesting, of course, that this could possibly apply to Norwich City or it''s two Cathedrals. 

He did distinguish between "many" "most" and "all".

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
[quote user="Camuldonum"][quote user="Camuldonum"][quote user="shyster"][quote user="Camuldonum"][quote user="venta icenorum"][quote user="PhatCanary"]

 If Roeder was given the funds,could he get us to the Premier League? 

[/quote]

He would certainly get us good players and assemble a very strong looking team, but would they get enough points on the board? Maybe after a few seasons of trying, although I still think that the playoffs would be our only route to the Prem as I can''t see us ever finding the consistency like Wolves/Birmingham can to be a top two side.

If only Roy Keane would come here!

[/quote]

 

You really wouldn''t want to know what Roy thinks (privately) about fans.  You really wouldn''t.

[/quote]

Come on, Camul-toe, tell the truth for once![/quote]

 

Okay, I don''t think you have the resources to be a Premier League club in the current set up.

[/quote]

PS: Mr Keane thinks that many football supporters are "not very bright and mostly couldn''t hold their place in a park side but they always seem to know what someone else should do.  Actually most of them are ******* thicker than the walls of Newcastle Cathedral."

That is not suggesting, of course, that this could possibly apply to Norwich City or it''s two Cathedrals. 

He did distinguish between "many" "most" and "all".

[/quote]I wont be quite so coy in telling you I think Roy Keane is a class A Nob, and wasn''t a particularly good footballer but one who traded an entire career on a ''Hard man'' reputation, thing is I firmly believe he only actually scared those who weren''t aware that anorexia isn''t contagious.Vicious in a snidy way yes, hard? No.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Just compare his current performance to other Championship managers in a similar financial position. That tells me that there are too many other managers around who will always keep their sides above him.  He appears tactically inept, a poor man manager and seems to have little idea of his best team.  He only seems to get his selection right when injuries and suspensions dictate who he can pick. 

I believe he will leave Norwich (hopefully sooner rather than later) without dignity and as the most despised manager we have ever had.   He is fortunate that he is managing Norwich at a time of low expectation and when the board are rightly taking the flack for their lack of ideas and leadership. 

A more pertinant question is whether given the funds he can keep us in the Championship for a second time.

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
[quote user="PhatCanary"]

 If Roeder was given the funds,could he get us to the Premier League? 

[/quote]

No, i don''t think he could because Roeder would be too stubborn to go for some bigger name players and would instead buy some player out of league 1 that gets about 5 goals a season instead of a young championhip striker that gets about 15 a season. PLus the fact he would still play Fotheringham even though i do not think he is up to championship standard. We would probably blow the money on a new hotel or a new bar anyway lol

Come on you yellows !!!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

if you had asked this 6 months ago i''d of said yes..... not so sure now... he''d probably sign a load of promising kids and last chancers, not sure they''d have the quality...

also, his tactical decisions are puzzling, his arrogance will be his down fall.

jas :)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  

×
×
  • Create New...