Who should our new manager be?

[Mister Chops 7]

Come on then, those of you who want Roeder out.  Who would you replace him with?  Names, please.

[roders 0]

someone whos not a delia yes man would help.

[First Wizard 0]

[quote user="Mister Chops"]Come on then, those of you who want Roeder out.  Who would you replace him with?  Names, please.

[/quote]Steve Tilson Mr C.....we went for him before appointing Grant, anned Saffend said no, remember?.........we should batter their door down again!

[hogesar 10,762]

[quote user="1st Wizard"][quote user="Mister Chops"]Come on then, those of you who want Roeder out.  Who would you replace him with?  Names, please.[/quote]Steve Tilson Mr C.....we went for him before appointing Grant, anned Saffend said no, remember?.........we should batter their door down again![/quote]Steve Tilson or Glenn Roeder. And Whats To Stop Southend Saying No Again Wiz? THEN What?

[singing canary 0]

ian crook..

[hogesar 10,762]

[quote user="topcanary1971"]ian crook..[/quote]LOL.

[norfolkbroadslim 225]

Given that we have limited funds if any especially after paying Roeder off, I think Clark would go too, so would some of the other coaches, it would have to be Bryan Gunn with Neil Adams as his assistant.[:O]

[singing canary 0]

great play maker very clever as a player loved the club got the passion bigger network of players,

[Have Heart 0]

[quote user="topcanary1971"]great play maker very clever as a player loved the club got the passion bigger network of players,[/quote]

LOL

[SWP = Poor Mans Ruel Fox!! 0]

[quote user="topcanary1971"]great play maker very clever as a player loved the club got the passion bigger network of players,[/quote]

 

Can you elaborate on that?  So after the Grant debacle you are advocating another novice manager taking over this club at a very difficult time, not a good idea imo.

Tilson may be a good choice Wiz, but it depends on the length of his contract and therefore how much compo we would be due to give to Southend.  We would have to pay off Roeder, then give compensation for Tilson and probably his backroom staff, have we got the money for that?

[First Wizard 0]

[quote user="hogesar"][quote user="1st Wizard"][quote user="Mister Chops"]Come on then, those of you who want Roeder out.  Who would you replace him with?  Names, please.

[/quote]Steve Tilson Mr C.....we went for him before appointing Grant, anned Saffend said no, remember?.........we should batter their door down again![/quote]

Steve Tilson or Glenn Roeder. And Whats To Stop Southend Saying No Again Wiz? THEN What?
[/quote]

Then we drop the ''nice little old Norwich'' tag hogesar, go back, and nag and nag till we get our own way...........you know?  just like 99% of other clubs do!

[singing canary 0]

forgive me if im wrong im sure crooks astrailian record is fairly good , i just have a feeling he would do a good job he was tactical as a player a real playmaker who with a hardman in midfield like andy townesend quick skillfull wingers fox gordon, it was the right mix , i think he would be respected more as he was really well liked always a bonus whilst being a manager.

[SWP = Poor Mans Ruel Fox!! 0]

[quote user="topcanary1971"]forgive me if im wrong im sure crooks astrailian record is fairly good , i just have a feeling he would do a good job he was tactical as a player a real playmaker who with a hardman in midfield like andy townesend quick skillfull wingers fox gordon, it was the right mix , i think he would be respected more as he was really well liked always a bonus whilst being a manager.[/quote]

Crook was a fantastic playmaker and someone who I loved to watch when he was playing with us.  He will hardly have any reputation in this country, do you reckon he will have the contacts in this country that someone like Roeder does seeing as he has not worked in this country for god knows how long?  Will that not put us back into the Grant situation of struggling even more to get in half decent players?

I agree that Roeder is not perfect, but I am not sure if there is a better option at the moment considering our position.

[Zachariah Lovespoon 0]

[quote user="Mister Chops"]Come on then, those of you who want Roeder out.  Who would you replace him with?  Names, please.

[/quote]

 

If the know nothing idiots get their way and Roeder is sacked there is not a chance in hell that we could afford a better replacement.  I don''t know why they don''t all just go and support Man United

[GJP 79]

Juande Ramos.

[Branston Pickle 4,149]

[quote user="1st Wizard"][quote user="Mister Chops"]Come on then, those of you who want Roeder out.  Who would you replace him with?  Names, please.

[/quote]Steve Tilson Mr C.....we went for him before appointing Grant, anned Saffend said no, remember?.........we should batter their door down again![/quote]

Er, if I remember correctly we asked to speak to any number of potential managers before settling with Roeder - it was not just Tilson, it included people like Pulis and Bowen, so who is to say that we wanted him any more than the others? Or, indeed, that he would do any better? 

IMO this is a pointless discussion, as Roeder should be going nowhere.  But even if we were looking, if we consider Roeder a failure with all his experience and links throughout the game, I''m not sure why getting someone who has only ever managed a lower side would be seen as being a particularly great forward step.

[singing canary 0]

because we dont want to support man united.. we want to support norwich all you are doing is making up excuses for the poor show we are seeing .

if we had won 5 or 6 games out of ten then my posts would be different if we carry on like this we will finish on 40 points ish..thats relegation form surely you must see that no disrespect only a fool would think thats good trouble is people are burrying thier heads in the sand.. our top scorer would finish on about 12 goals think about it

 

[yellow hammer 131]

The manager of Asda for me. He gets most of the country''s leading footballers sulking around the frozen food cabinets, apparently. He must have great contacts in the game

[trowsevilla 0]

How about that nasty,mean,angry,do it my way or else man .  I''am talking about Billie davies, that man would shake us up pronto.

[singing canary 0]

we would get buy one player get one free!!

[Ex-greenoschin 0]

[quote user="topcanary1971"]forgive me if im wrong im sure crooks astrailian record is fairly good , i just have a feeling he would do a good job he was tactical as a player a real playmaker who with a hardman in midfield like andy townesend quick skillfull wingers fox gordon, it was the right mix , i think he would be respected more as he was really well liked always a bonus whilst being a manager.[/quote]

Jeeezzzz  TC you''ve spent ages banging the drum about get Roeder out and this is your best effort at a replacement, you''re entitled to your opinion obviously, but you don''t even sound convinced yourself!!!

Before you ask I appreciate things aint rosy but I also believe you don''t go changing Managers annually and feel he will do a better job working within our  financial constraints than anyone else realistically available.

 

OTBC

[Lurd 0]

[quote user="Ex-greenoschin"]

[quote user="topcanary1971"]forgive me if im wrong im sure crooks astrailian record is fairly good , i just have a feeling he would do a good job he was tactical as a player a real playmaker who with a hardman in midfield like andy townesend quick skillfull wingers fox gordon, it was the right mix , i think he would be respected more as he was really well liked always a bonus whilst being a manager.[/quote]

Jeeezzzz  TC you''ve spent ages banging the drum about get Roeder out and this is your best effort at a replacement, you''re entitled to your opinion obviously, but you don''t even sound convinced yourself!!!

Before you ask I appreciate things aint rosy but I also believe you don''t go changing Managers annually and feel he will do a better job working within our  financial constraints than anyone else realistically available.

 

OTBC

[/quote]I doubt any of our players even know who Ian Crook even is. He has no record at all over here, just an average record as an ASSISTANT in the world renowned hot bed of football, Australia..

[singing canary 0]

oh i didnt think it was that long ago australia beat england?

[NCFC_Shaun 0]

Think we should have got Mark Bowen when we could. Wouldn''t leave now he''s at the richest club in the world, would he?

[Lurd 0]

[quote user="topcanary1971"]oh i didnt think it was that long ago australia beat england?[/quote]It was about 6 years ago and as I recall, Ian Crook was not involved..

[Syteanric 1]

i want Roeder as manager and dont want him to leave... if he did decide to cut his losses i wont blame him though... would want to see Steve Tilson come in but think it will be one of delais "pals" who get the nod again...

jas :)

[Lurd 0]

[quote user="jas the barclay king"]

i want Roeder as manager and dont want him to leave... if he did decide to cut his losses i wont blame him though... would want to see Steve Tilson come in but think it will be one of delais "pals" who get the nod again...

jas :)

[/quote]I don''t get the Steve Tilson love. He did quite well with Southend a few years ago, but no better than countless other lower league managers.

[Syteanric 1]

[quote user="Larry David"][quote user="jas the barclay king"]

i want Roeder as manager and dont want him to leave... if he did decide to cut his losses i wont blame him though... would want to see Steve Tilson come in but think it will be one of delais "pals" who get the nod again...

jas :)

[/quote]

I don''t get the Steve Tilson love. He did quite well with Southend a few years ago, but no better than countless other lower league managers.


[/quote]

not been given a chance to prove himself with a bigger club though.. although perhaps there is a reason for that... i think he could step up though

jas :)

[Mister Chops 7]

[quote user="1st Wizard"][quote user="Mister Chops"]Come on then, those of you who want Roeder out.  Who would you replace him with?  Names, please.[/quote]Steve Tilson Mr C.....we went for him before appointing Grant, anned Saffend said no, remember?.........we should batter their door down again![/quote]The same Steve Tilson who took Southend United out of League One and then took them back down to League One again?  That''s ambitious.

[Lurd 0]

[quote user="Mister Chops"][quote user="1st Wizard"][quote user="Mister Chops"]Come on then, those of you who want Roeder out.  Who would you replace him with?  Names, please.[/quote]Steve Tilson Mr C.....we went for him before appointing Grant, anned Saffend said no, remember?.........we should batter their door down again![/quote]The same Steve Tilson who took Southend United out of League One and then took them back down to League One again?  That''s ambitious.[/quote]Ridiculous isn''t it? Though his knowledge of football probably consists of what he sees on Anglia News..