Jump to content
Sign in to follow this  

Any Player ratings for the Barnsley match?

Recommended Posts

the norwich fans completely outvoiced the home side, we didnt hear a peep from them all game..

my ratings,

Marshall - 8 (thought he couldve done more with their goal)

Otsemobor - 8 (great runs up the right)

Doherty - 7 (solid towards the end but looked shakey first half)

Shackell - 7 (ditto)

Camara - 6 (ditto, made a couple of alarming mistakes 1st half)

Croft - 9 (superb running and effort, good crossing)

Bertrand - 6 (looked a bit naive and inexperienced on the ball, but some promising vision and pace)

Fotheringham - 9 (fantastic commanding of midfield and great passing)

Russell - 8 (great effort and determination, passing a touch off though)

Evans - 8 (made some great runs and got into great positions, awesome goal)

Dublin - 8 (fantastic player esp 2nd half, very creative in the final third)


cureton - 6 didnt have the same presence as evans

huckerby - 8 really caused problems for their left back

jarvis - 6 cant really make a comment, was only on a couple of minutes

overall a fantastic day out, best away day for a long time!

Especially liked it when Glenn gave us all a wave from the stands when we asked, Delia was also at the game!

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

overall, the first half performance was woeful, particularly the first half hour or so. Barnsley didn''t play that well themselves in the first half but a goal was inevitable because of the way city were playing. There wasn''t any tackling, pressing or significant challenge and the passing just wasn''t good enough.

The devaney goal was soft, otsemobor caught out from the left and doherty not filling the space and closing down, very poor defending. After that city settled a bit and at least started to retain possession towards the end of the half. The problem then was a complete lack of ideas and no movement. Dion Dublin seemed to spend a lot of time supporting bertrand over on the left and it was hard to see exactly where he was supposed to be playing. He seemed to be playing behind Evans. Evans was the one bright spark in the first half, looking lively and having several shots, although none of them significantly tested their keeper.

At half time i wouldn''t have given a cat in hells chance of city getting anything out of the game, they looked scared, and as though they weren''t up for the game. In summary they had barely turned up. So the second half performance was nothing short of a miraculous transformation. I''m not sure what Glenn Roeder must''ve said or done at half time, or what was in the lucozade bottles in order to get that sort of turn around but whatever it was it worked a treat.

Pressure, closing down, tackles, pushing up, counter-attacking, it was all there. Croft''s pace was finally starting to be used. Dion Dublin was immence in the second half. Darel Russel seemed to be everywhere. And Mark Fotheringham was superb. He passed the ball well and he got forwards. 2 assists and a goal (although heavily deflected) says it all about his attacking efforts. His through ball for evans'' goal was perfect and a clinical finish followed. After that Croft hit the post from close range in a one on one with their frankly rubbish keeper and he should''ve scored. A great chance for 2-1. Well done for the goal fozzy, and the corner for the 3rd goal was excellent. Dublin missed a sitter from close range after hucks crossed the ball from the by-line. Hucks looked a class apart when he came on for croft and the barnsley left back appeared scared to death by his very prescence.

Overall the second half performance was terrific, it''s no exaggeration to say that we SHOULD HAVE won by at least 5-1, with those 2 sitters being missed, but there was plenty of other good efforts as well.

marshall - 6

otsemobor - 6 (better defensively in the 2nd half but poor crossing throughout)

Shackell - 5 (looked nervous and the weak link in the defence)

Doherty - 7 (poor defending for the goal, but generally very good in the tackle, it''s a shame his distribution isn''t better)

Camara - 6 (fairly solid defensively)

Bertrand - 6 (awful first half, solid second half, appeared to work well with camara. Not a bad debut overall)

Fotheringham - 8 (superb in the second half, led by example and was obviously firmly commited. Good all round performance)

Russel - 7 (seemed to get everywhere in the second half, could''ve got himself a goal with a bit more luck_

Croft - 6 (full of running and was very useful with the counter-attacking style in the second half. Missed an easy chance and too often his final ball let him down. Produced only one acceptable cross all afternoon)

Dublin - 7 (took the goal very well but missed an easier chance later on, held the ball up well and won a lot of aerial battles, his passing and vision were very good in the second half)

Evans - 7 (looks like a great prospecy, got himself in good positions and was quick to get his shots away, a quiet second half after his goal. Lacks movement off the ball at times)

(subs cureton 6, Hucks 7, jarvis 6).


Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites
Posted by NCFC_Chris on 12 Jan 2008 20:16 Complain | Prev | Next | Reply

Ratings ...

i''ll do 1st half and 2nd half ratings

Marshall - 7, no chance with goal, handling was very good

Otsemobor - 4 - 8, alongside croft he tore their left back apart but 1st half he was pushed back and looked all over place

doherty - 4 - 7, the good and bad of doherty, clumsy oaf and then dominant centre back

shackell - 5 - 7, similar to doherty

camara - 5 - 7, campbell-ryce caused a few problems 1st half but in 2nd half camara/bertrand had him in their pockets

croft - 5 - 9, didnt really a get a chance to cause problems in 1st half but in 2nd half he was unstoppable at times

rusty - 5 - 8, never got near opposition in 1st half but in the 2nd he was 1st to it everytime

fozzy - 5 - 9, similar to rusty but he scored 1 and created the other 2, scotland call up got to be close

bertrand - 4 - 7, nightmare 1st half but linked well with camara and others well in 2nd, doesnt look a winger to me but tracked back a lot and allowed camara to go forward so should be good at full back

dion - 5 - 8, scraps in 1st half but part of everything good in 2nd half

ched - 6 - 8, just about the only bright spark in dire 1st half

hucks - 7, forced to play on right when came on but he really looked dangerous

cureton - 6, caused problems

jarvis - not enough time

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

What a game.  Rubbish first 45 and at half time I was wondering why I had travelled all that way and then incredible in the 2nd half.  Croft and Fozzy outstanding.  Croft simply tore them apart.


Marshall 7, no real chance with goal
Otsemobor 7 at fault in lead up to their goal.  Great support for Crofty 2nd half
doherty 6 exposed in first half much improved in 2nd

shackell 6 ok game 
camara 7 poor first great second

Croft 9, score mainly for 2nd half when he was simply fantastic ! best 45 minutes by any City player this season
rusty 7  Lost in first half but everywhere in the 2nd

fozzy 8  really dominant in 2nd half another great performance
bertrand - 6 supported Camara well but not very creative 
dion 7 led line well

ched 7 took goal well and caused lots of probs in 2nd half

hucks 7, continued the torment of Barnsley but by then they were on the canvas 
cureton 6, a late irritant
jarvis not on long enough to judge

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  

  • Create New...