zemas tendon 0 Posted September 28, 2007 GK Marshall £750kRB Ostemboor £500k and risingCB Doc £250kCB Shacks £1millionLB Drury £350kMF Lappin £400kMF Rusty £400kMF Le Judge £200kMF Fozzy £400kMF Hucks N/AMF Spillane £500 and RisingMF Jarvis(Rossi) £250kMF Chadders £100kMF Croft £400kST Cureton £500kST Brown £350kST Dublin £N/AST Dave £200kDF/MF Murray £75kST Ryan Jarvis £FreeWere In Trouble Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
The_Canary_90 0 Posted September 28, 2007 how do u come to the conclusion that shackel is worht £1m that is an aboslute joke and brellier''s £200k is generous after wolves, why is hucks n/a Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Indy_Bones 441 Posted September 28, 2007 [quote user="zemas tendon"]We''re In Trouble[/quote]Err...noWe have a very similar level of player value to almost every other club in this league, in fact it''s quite superior to at least 50% of the other teams.It would also help if you''d got more accurate and correct figures for some of the players instead of either dreaming them up or hoping that Football Manager has it bang on...Croft has certainly not de-valued by £300k in the last year, neither is Shacks worth 4 times more than Doherty (even that I don''t rate Doc), and quite how you think we''ve lost over £500k already on Strihavka is unbelievable.We have quite a young team overall that has potential to improve, and with some shrewd signings and change in tactics we''d be playing far better. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Carlos Valderrama 0 Posted September 28, 2007 I think you have been a little understated with some (not all) of your values. In todays climate especially I think that you have pitched a bit low. Your list with a few amended by me.....GK Marshall £1mRB Ostemboor £1m (if he maintains his current progress)CB Doc £250kCB Shacks £1millionLB Drury £1m (lack of decent left backs about and Drury is a decent left back)MF Lappin £400kMF Rusty £800kMF Le Judge £500k - £1m (contentious after recent performances but this bloke missed pre-season and is playing catch up. If he had had 4/5 pre season games he would probably have ironed out his poor form. As it is he is having to do it in matches. This bloke is not a bad player he just isn''t in the best form)MF Fozzy £400kMF Hucks N/AMF Spillane £500k and Rising (Agree, the sky is the limit for this kid. Better we continue to develop him and then get decent money for him as opposed to let him go for peanuts now - NOT FOR SALE YET)MF Jarvis(Rossi) £250k - Doubt we could get a fee for him yet.MF Chadwick £100k - Potentially 750k if he pulls his finger out and plays like he did at stokeMF Croft £1m - Dont forget that he is still young, the potential is there he just needs to stay away from Burger KingST Cureton £500kST Brown £350kST Dublin £N/AST Dave £200k - There is no way on this earth we will sell DS for less than we paid. Remember it takes a season to adjust to the english league. This guy is one for later this.or next season - £1m + when he develops...DF/MF Murray £75k - Fair at the moment but only 26/27, capped full international, Rangers only released him becuase he was A. Surplus and B. they needed to free up some of the wage bill. Potentially worth considerably more... £500k plusST Ryan Jarvis £Free I am not rubbishing your valuations. Quite the opposite, I think that they are very fair at the moment. However once the new boys settle down properly and others start playing like we know they can then we will be looking at these values in a different light.Cheap while off form, expensive when on form. Its up to PG to get them playing so we can get top price... Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
zemas tendon 0 Posted September 28, 2007 In my opinion Shacks is worth a hundred times more than Doc, and you obviously havent seen Dave play, he is no better than Olf Ottosson, and Croft has''nt exactly set the world a-light, i also take then that we are the first club ever to sign a player whos value never decreases!!!!!!!!!! Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
zemas tendon 0 Posted September 28, 2007 Oh i forgot your value of things in Rotherham are different to those in Norfolk!!! Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
7rew 0 Posted September 28, 2007 Presonally I would say that Shackell is worth marginally more than the doc, but only because he is younger and left footed. Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
