Idah isn't very good

[TeemuVanBasten 3,328]

There, I've said it.

I saw more in Carlton Morris at his age, definitely more between the ears.

He isn't going to cut the mustard.

[Canary Wundaboy 1,409]

I sadly agree.

[Worthy Nigelton 1,232]

Shame to say it, but I agree with this. He's shown nothing to me to suggest he has a future at any sort of level at all.

[Ward 3 459]

Unfortunately you are right. As someone said on match thread he does a lot of running around like a lost little boy.was hoping he would do something tonight. Maybe he should've taken the penalty?

[Virtual reality 819]

Agreed. 

[sgncfc 1,306]

Have to say I was just thinking the same thing. I'm not sure what they see in him at this level or even last season in the Championship. I mean no disrespect to the lad; he tries hard and presumably he does things in training we don't see. But when he has been on the pitch he has always looked quite poor.

Tzolis obviously didn't have a great game, but he was streets ahead of Idah.

[birchfest 401]

A lot of running, but so far not seeing anything that would suggest he's going to solve our lack of goals. I want anyone who pulls on the yellow and green to succeed, but 2 tame shots and the second an awful decision to not square it to pukki for a tap in. Should also have backed himself as the penalty taker. 

[Olano 110]

I dont agere.

He needs a season in the championship. Hope he can find a Lone move in january

[Well b back 3,570]

Don’t tell Lakey 

[Tetteys Jig 847]

He's massively stagnated for sure... this year should have been a year out on loan to make or break him. Just not up to it at prem level in the slightest. Looks like a scared little boy, hence why a year out on loan getting experience would have done him good.

[Sideshow Tim 110]

Thought that for a while sadly. 

[Son Ova Gunn 165]

Idah not know what he offers. Club rate him highly and the other players seem to as well, can only assume he plays like Maradona in training because in games he doesn’t look anywhere near the standard required

[nfkboy21 3]

I been thinking this for ages. He wouldn't do anything if he was on loan at Kings Lynn.

[Faded Jaded Semi Plastic SOB 1,196]

Agree, I suppose that the positive from this is it puts to bed the calls for him to be starting instead of Pukki..........

[birchfest 401]

1 minute ago, Olano said:

I dont agere.

He needs a season in the championship. Hope he can find a Lone move in january

Yeah THIS, he has to go and play a full season somewhere, its not going to work any other way.

[Hank shoots Skyler 2,094]

You mean, Idah wasn’t very good tonight*

Injuries stopped him from playing more last season, which was a shame, but seen plenty of flashes from him to think there is something there. He just hasn’t had a solid run to prove himself properly, has been playing very well internationally though. 

Honestly if you want to pick out individual players based on these opening games of the season then you end up writing everyone off.

Idah was wasteful tonight, but so was Tzolis. All of the back line were ropey, the midfield offered next to nothing bar from Gilmour.

No need to single anyone out, we simply have to get better as a group. 

[HazzaJet 265]

I’m still not convinced with him yet and like others said over the summer, I thought he could benefit from a Championship loan this season. Felt he would have converted the penalty though 

[Ward 3 459]

1 minute ago, Son Ova Gunn said:

Idah not know what he offers. Club rate him highly and the other players seem to as well, can only assume he plays like Maradona in training because in games he doesn’t look anywhere near the standard required

Maradona in training, Madonna on the pitch.

[Dean Coneys boots 1,484]

I think he will end up lower champs at best in his career- looked toothless today 

[Ward 3 459]

1 minute ago, Hank shoots Skyler said:

You mean, Idah wasn’t very good tonight*

Injuries stopped him from playing more last season, which was a shame, but seen plenty of flashes from him to think there is something there. He just hasn’t had a solid run to prove himself properly, has been playing very well internationally though. 

Honestly if you want to pick out individual players based on these opening games of the season then you end up writing everyone off.

Idah was wasteful tonight, but so was Tzolis. All of the back line were ropey, the midfield offered next to nothing bar from Gilmour.

No need to single anyone out, we simply have to get better as a group. 

To me, rupp was better than Gilmour tonight. Bring on some sh1t comments.

[norfolkngood 1,171]

i was Excited about Idah getting a chance at the start of the season

but after tonight might ask Adrian Coote if he can bring his boots for our  next match 

[FCC 94]

Not progressed.  Selfish, but can’t finish, not a good combination.

[Worthy Nigelton 1,232]

3 minutes ago, Hank shoots Skyler said:

You mean, Idah wasn’t very good tonight*

Injuries stopped him from playing more last season, which was a shame, but seen plenty of flashes from him to think there is something there. He just hasn’t had a solid run to prove himself properly, has been playing very well internationally though. 

Honestly if you want to pick out individual players based on these opening games of the season then you end up writing everyone off.

Idah was wasteful tonight, but so was Tzolis. All of the back line were ropey, the midfield offered next to nothing bar from Gilmour.

No need to single anyone out, we simply have to get better as a group. 

10 caps, zero goals. The one game I saw him against England he was poor in that as well.

[Dame to Blame 105]

Ive have never really rated him

[Wacky Waving Inflatable Arm Flailing Tube Man 4,486]

He has started about five or six games in his club career and he's unlikely to add to that this season.

The problem is that he has never had a proper run of games, as these ten-minute cameos in the league and the odd run out in the cup isn't really doing much for him.

I do feel that if he gets a run of games somewhere then he'll come good, but he's 21 in February so needs one soon.

[Yellow Shirt 17]

I can’t disagree. I would have liked to have seen Sargent tonight

[Disco Dales Jockstrap 1,958]

He's a bit better than Dean Coney but not as good as the mighty Darren Beckford.

OTBC

[ncfc-tom 50]

Was really pleased to see him start tonight at the end was really dissapointed he started tonight.

[rock bus 1,006]

I’ve always questioned why people have raved about him

Time is over for his ‘potential’ just not good enough I’m afraid

[Fraz 2]

Yeah needs a year on loan in league 1, because he got that hat trick against Preston the club think that he will produce it again, never really happened