Best players per number

[AJ 1,358]

Another one for a bit of fun, after discussing recently who our best no10 and 9 have been, would be interesting to see some opinions, what are your best #1-11? 

1 Green

2 Aarons

3 Drury

4 Mackay

5 Hanley

6 Huckerby

7 Eadie

8 Fleck

9 Holt

10 Fox 

11 Goss

 

[Indy_Bones 444]

1) Keelan

2) Culverhouse

3) Bowen

4) Sutton

5) Fleming

6) Hucks

7) Eadie

8  Crook

9) Fashanu

10) Fox

11) Phillips

[Branston Pickle 4,145]

This is one where people’s ages will show!!  I’ve tried to make this a ‘realistic’ XI in terms of formation, but the numbers are probably all over the shop.  I might go:  

1 Woods

2 Culverhouse,

3 Bowen 

4 Linighan

5 Watson

6 Hucks

7 Gordon

8 Townsend

9 Holt

10 Crook 

11 Eadie,

[BigFish 2,282]

16 minutes ago, Branston Pickle said:

This is one where people’s ages will show!!  I’ve tried to make this a ‘realistic’ XI in terms of formation, but the numbers are probably all over the shop.  I might go:  

1 Woods

2 Culverhouse,

3 Bowen 

4 Linighan

5 Watson

6 Hucks

7 Gordon

8 Townsend

9 Holt

10 Crook 

11 Eadie,

Certainly does @Branston Pickle, also having an influence is whether players were on the way up, way down or peaked at City. No one so far has included World Cup Final scorer Martin Peters who was still doing it City towards the end of his career. Steve Bruce went on to win 3 EPL titles, 3 FA Cups, a Euro Cup Winners Cup & Super Cup. Phil Boyer, who is often forgotton went on to be the top scorer in the old First Division. Chris Sutton went for a record fee and Fashanu scored that goal, amongst others. In contrast, Keelan was here for so long he seemed part of the furniture. Holt didn't achieve much before or after but left happy memories, although I think it means he is overrated on these list. So here goes......

1 Woods

2 Culverhouse,

3 Aarons

4 Crook 

5 Watson

6 Bruce

7 Huckerby

8 Fashanu

9 Sutton

10 Peters

11 Eadie

[Branston Pickle 4,145]

I was thinking of Keelan and Peters, but limited it to players I saw in the flesh - my first game aged 8 was a 4-0 loss to the binners at Portman Road (Easter 78), but I didn’t go again until I was at secondary school in the early 80s.

Edited June 26, 2021 by Branston Pickle

[AJ 1,358]

13 minutes ago, BigFish said:

 Holt didn't achieve much before or after but left happy memories, although I think it means he is overrated on these list. So here goes....

Some of those are before my time, I was early 90s so didn't have the joy of seeing some of the older club legend. 

Disagree about Holt, 2 promotions and Premier League survival in his first 3 seasons scoring a lot of goals in the process as well as being incredibly talismanic. Definitely the best 9 since the 90s

[Grantham yellow 20]

New to the forum although lurked for years. Couldn’t resist this. Numbers might not be right, but given the choice this is my team based purely on memory.
 

1. Keelan

2. Culverhouse

3. Aarons

4. Watson

5. Forbes

6. Crooks

7. Peters

8. Huckerby

9. Buendia

10. Macdougal

11. Ash man

Edited June 26, 2021 by Grantham yellow
Spelling

[king canary 8,749]

6 hours ago, BigFish said:

Certainly does @Branston Pickle, also having an influence is whether players were on the way up, way down or peaked at City. No one so far has included World Cup Final scorer Martin Peters who was still doing it City towards the end of his career. Steve Bruce went on to win 3 EPL titles, 3 FA Cups, a Euro Cup Winners Cup & Super Cup. Phil Boyer, who is often forgotton went on to be the top scorer in the old First Division. Chris Sutton went for a record fee and Fashanu scored that goal, amongst others. In contrast, Keelan was here for so long he seemed part of the furniture. Holt didn't achieve much before or after but left happy memories, although I think it means he is overrated on these list. So here goes......

1 Woods

2 Culverhouse,

3 Aarons

4 Crook 

5 Watson

6 Bruce

7 Huckerby

8 Fashanu

9 Sutton

10 Peters

11 Eadie

I dont think Huckerby ever wore 7 or Aarons 3? Unless I'm misunderstanding the rules of this.

[HazzaJet 267]

1 hour ago, king canary said:

I dont think Huckerby ever wore 7 or Aarons 3? Unless I'm misunderstanding the rules of this.

I think it’s your greatest starting XI

[Norfolk Dan 336]

21 minutes ago, HazzaJet said:

I think it’s your greatest starting XI

But the title of the post is best players by numbers... 

[Norfolk Dan 336]

I will go with players I have watched in a city shirt, wearing 1-11 or playing in that number position.e.g 3 is left back... 

 

1 Gunn (Brian)

2 Culverhouse,

3 Bowen 

4 Newsome

5 Mackay

6 Hucks

7 Eadie

8  Holt (3lungs)

9 Sutton (Sub Pukki #22)

10 Ashton (Sub Buendía  #17) 

11  Crook 

 

Edits...fixed the players who have not worn the right shirt numbers..Subbed out those who have not worn the shirt! 

Edited June 26, 2021 by Norfolk Dan
See edit note

[The Great Mass Debater 1,202]

This might help. Wish Id found this before Id finalised my 11!

https://www.transfermarkt.co.uk/norwich-city/rueckennummern/verein/1123

[The Great Mass Debater 1,202]

1 Krul

2 Aarons

3 Bowen

4 Crook

5 Bassong

6 Huckerby

7 Eadie

8 Bellamy

9 Holt

10 Ashton 

11 Phillips (Peters - though on reputation only, never saw him play)

[splendidrush 720]

I'm waiting for someone to include Fozzy....... loading 🔫

[LaUnionCanary 149]

4 hours ago, The Great Mass Debater said:

This might help. Wish Id found this before Id finalised my 11!

https://www.transfermarkt.co.uk/norwich-city/rueckennummern/verein/1123

Our greatest goalie is not on that list. I refer, of course, to Michael Theoklitoris.

[BigFish 2,282]

15 hours ago, king canary said:

I dont think Huckerby ever wore 7 or Aarons 3? Unless I'm misunderstanding the rules of this.

 

13 hours ago, HazzaJet said:

I think it’s your greatest starting XI

I pretty much saw it as @HazzaJet saw it, @king canary. But it is just a bit of fun, so get some perspective.

That said I did it in a hurry and would probably swap Aarons to 2 and bring in Bowen at 3.

Happy now?

[Aggy 944]

On numbers worn and favourite players rather than technically ‘best’ or most balanced squad. 25 man squad. Using TGMD’s link to help my memory/sneak some in who switched numbers ….
 

1 - Green

2 - Aarons

3 - Drury

4 - Mackay

5 - Russ Martin

6 - Huckerby

7 - Snodgrass

8 - Bellamy

9 - Iwan (tricky with Holt)

10 - Ashton

11 - Gary Holt

12 - Doherty

14 - Hoolahan

15 - Safri 

16 - Olsson

 17 - Buendia

18 - McVeigh

19 - Lappin

20 - Eadie

21 - Paul Gallacher

22 - Pukki

23 - Maddison

24 - Howson

27 - Tettey

30 - Bassong

 

Turned out more balanced than I thought. Reckon that’s a top half prem squad easy! 

[king canary 8,749]

1 hour ago, BigFish said:

 

I pretty much saw it as @HazzaJet saw it, @king canary. But it is just a bit of fun, so get some perspective.

That said I did it in a hurry and would probably swap Aarons to 2 and bring in Bowen at 3.

Happy now?

Get out the wrong side of the bed today? Bit ott.

[Faded Jaded Semi Plastic SOB 1,220]

Based on players I have seen playing and taking the shirt number literally (thank you to LA Union Canary)  rather than position:

1. Kevin Keelan

2. Mark Bowen

3.  Ian Culverhouse

4.  Steve Bruce

5.  Duncan Forbes

6.  Ian Crook

7. Dale Gordon

8.  Craig Bellamy

9. Martin Peters

10. Dean Ashton

11. Robert Fleck

 

 

 

 

[splendidrush 720]

50 minutes ago, Faded Jaded Semi Plastic SOB said:

Based on players I have seen playing and taking the shirt number literally (thank you to LA Union Canary)  rather than position:

1. Kevin Keelan

2. Mark Bowen

3.  Ian Culverhouse

4.  Steve Bruce

5.  Duncan Forbes

6.  Ian Crook

7. Dale Gordon

8.  Craig Bellamy

9. Martin Peters

10. Dean Ashton

11. Robert Fleck

 

 

 

 

.....best so far..... 👍

[All the Germans 1,236]

1. Gunn

2. Culverhouse

3. Bowen

4. Bruce

5. Linighan

6. Hucks.

7. Eadie

8. Crook

9. Sutton

10 Phelan

11. Phillips

 

[Yobocop 1,441]

1. Krul 

2. Aarons 

3. Drury 

4. Mackay 

5. Whitbread 

6. Huckerby 

7. Eadie

8. Bellamy

9. Sutton 

10. Leitner 

11. Jarvis 
 

[Norfolk Dan 336]

@Yobocop if the best #5 you have watched in yellow and green is Whitbread, I feel for you! You must have picked some bad games to watch to turn up that result!