Indy

I agree and this is where clear and obvious is at the discretion of the VAR official! I really think VAR should taken away for offside, it’s crap for that with those two lines and when the ball is adjudged to be moving forwards! Just let the officials judge it on the pitch! I’m in agreement with others use the three challenge per half to the two managers, they can have an NFL style team viewing a live stream of the game and if it’s a clear and obvious mistake let the challenge it! But only for thing like penalty awards missed, off the ball incidents and clear cut mistakes, otherwise just get on with the game! Every goal now is bought back to ensure there’s no foul in the build up! Dodgy offside or anything else! As you correctly say Nutty it kills the game, restrict the challenges to three per team or do away with it all together!

Even that one had a touch of offside!

No I thought it was OK, I froze the picture on my tv I drew the two lines across my screen and definitely on side! (PS I hate Ipswich) 😂👍

Chelsea free kick, arm out the same deflected! 10 yards away his arm out to the side. Youngs arm was away from his body, it stopped the ball getting into the attacker and his arms motion was towards the ball! It wasn’t deflect, so hand ball, you can say it would have been harsh but what is the law regarding handball?

Only if it was a Binner in there! Or perhaps a Leeds fan! It matters! Or who offers the biggest back hander?

VAR would overturn it to offside! 😂😂 〰️

Makes no odds as wasn’t given, but I disagree it wasn’t point blank and his arm motioned towards the ball in slowmo. Of course it’s subjective and I bet you have a preference for the two teams involved here! I assume then you think Grealish handball was correct too? Boy ball to arm?

I try not to be too critical of the on pitch officials as they do their choice at match speed, and sometimes they don’t have the best line of sight! VAR is there for that! As we agree two of those Forrest chances were definitely penalties and clear and obvious mistakes, I’m convinced had that been Manure both should have been overturned and awarded! You can call it corruption or favouritism but VAR interpretation must be made easy and clear! Additionally I agree that no official with allegiance with clubs directly or indirectly which could influence the choice of VAR should be there or you make it a three man panel with a majority vote. Might take more time but takes away the risk?

I think the clear instruction is that if the arm is out stretching in an unnatural position or moving to the ball then it’s a penalty, that was clear handball as clear as it gets! Second the challenge from behind never made contact with the ball but made clear contact with the man definitely a penalty! So VAR hardly had hard choices to make both were clear and obvious mistakes and again had that been a more high profile side with out like United or Man City they’d both be awarded! Biased or not the VAR was shocking and I was pro VAR but totally against it as it now appeared to be another tool to protect the big boys, yesterday’s FA cup offside proves that! **** poor development of something which could have been a great addition.

Coventry robbed, it’s clear that this VAR offside is just not correct, you can’t draw two lines between the players in that picture, you could move one millimetre and he’d be onside. No room for error especially as when should the flag gone up, as the ball makes contact with the player passing or when it has forwards motion? It’s all open to the VAR had that been a Man U goal I actually think they would have given it and drawn the lines the frame in favour! VAR is utterly ****e! Also Bassaka’s knee is ahead of his boot yet the line is drawn to through his boot and even that looks as though it’s not at the end of his boot! It’s crazy that! I hate Manure & City both are the reason football in this country has become so boring! Buy the league and then by complaining so much change our traditional cup format!

Yeh I’m no lover of Forest but two of those were clear and obvious, third probably was too! I’d be fuming too to be honest, what’s the point of VAR! The trouble I have is that the soft penalty given to the big sides given all the time by refs and yet here they don’t give all! Surely it should be a constant of give all close call penalties and review the VAR, because each one was a clear penalty!

Yes looked it but take the point. Just watching Forest v Everton, two absolutely clear penalties not given to forest! Can’t believe the soft penalty awarded to top teams yet others don’t get a sniff even with VAR. so as above take the rough with the smooth!

It used to be the prestige event, I remember watching the live cup finals and loving the build up! Everything has gone it’s now viewed as a tinpot competition! The only way to get it back is for replays to stay that’s a lifeline of small clubs to get a big club at home get a draw and get that big payday away. Also give the winners a Champions League award!

No worries, on coke as driving! Pint later. Have good one LYB, nothing wrong I being passionate. PS that’s Cola not Coke powder kind! 😂😂

Religion which teaches intolerance is awful, most religions teach their believers their story to live life by! That in itself teaches certain view point in most religions which then gives those of extreme views tools to use in hate, that’s not restricted to just Muslims but other ms too! Of course there’s also a lot of good done by religion too! Just take away extremes and teach tolerance! I’ve said from day one the abhorrent actions were inexcusable but the response has been too in the Ghetto Like annexing was truly terrible and something that shouldn’t have been done! There’s a lot of Israeli’s critical of the actions of their governments. Anyhow I’m now at the pub, I apologise for calling you vile, maybe the remark should have been marked as vile! Let’s agree to disagree on what has been said as I’ve got a life to get too! 👍

Yes as I’ve stated always the abhorrent actions of Hamas, the indefensible Iranian regime, but there’s no justification for Israel to have a free card as you suggest because of history! It should never be used in an excuse for the actions! Maybe you should rethink what you posted and be humble enough to actually say you’re wrong in your statement yesterday! Lastly exactly my point, you obviously never read the threads properly as have always condemned hideous actions from all sides, I don’t have a side I have a thought process on humans not Arabs as you refer to them or Israeli I see them all as normal people being effected by the few who are not fit to walk this earth! No different to most Russian or Ukrainians they just want a peaceful life, but religious groups teach to build up hatred and incompatibility which leads to boundary conflicts and where we are now! There are no good v evil here it’s just prejudice from the few, normal people don’t think this way and children shouldn’t be tonight to hate! End off, as for reporting you as I said that one statement you made was vile in the context but I just sent your post of mine you doctored to fit your narrative to the moderator and asked why this can be done as I think your posts should be locked.

Because there’s nothing there that’s why! They probably took it down as you justified in one statement your support & justified remark for Israel for killing 30,000 innocent people. Ask them they will tell you why and for that inhuman comment I view that as a vile remark! End off but you never go back and humbly change your view you just deflect and attack like a troll! So there you are best leave trying to justify yourself by attacking me for nothing I’ve actually said but something I haven’t, that’s sad. That’s the end from me as I’m off to footy.

See there you go again, so now glossing over is your argument, I never bought it up you did, as for insults well you would know and I fully stand by my view after your statement that you are vile! Lastly I didn’t report you I asked the moderator about people taking your post and being able to quote and change it! As you did to troll! So report all you like my old troll I stand by my entire response to you. so that said leave it off the threads and stop derailing threads it’s boring and obvious you just want to keep arguing! Bye troll.

I never dismissed anything I never even referred to it, you in some daft sidetrack excuse bought it up to try and justify your statement of the killing of 30,000 innocent people, instead of doing the decent thing and backing down. Exactly what you do on here deflect instead of back down when you’ve said something pretty abhorrent! Then all you do is troll for argument like this until someone bites! Just look at your posts and how many times you end up causing conflict on here! Still never mind like I said you’re a very strange individual and I’m glad I don’t have you as a friend with you’re attitude towards people of certain ethnicity! Anyhow I’m not going to let you derail another thread to your liking…..back to the thread!

You are, your comment about justifying the killing of 30,000 innocent people because it’s the Jewish doing it was vile! You should take a leaf out of your own preaching and read before you post! Also respond to posts don’t amend others for your own self need of trolling! Got called out by what you’re derailment of something I never said? You’re a troll that’s All you and an angry little one too!

Off you go again proving my point! Angry little troll again! One track and have the nerve to criticise a poster and you’re the worst culprit on here! All you do is come on to cause a fight every thread you try to derail to your theme, you really are a sad man. Feel so sorry for you. Now calm down dear or you’ll blow a fuse! 😂 But it was comedy gold from you, almost as good as your Smott thread meltdown!

Utterly deserved and what an outstanding individual. Congratulations to Westy…….legend.

Now that’s the funniest thing I’ve read on here in years coming from you! Pot & Kettle! You might want to take your advice and apply it to yourself!

Yeh yeh here you go again, you justified the mass killing of the Palestinians! And you call me a hypocrite for pulling you up! Now go away you I really don’t want to be associated with such vile person!

What insults you’ve made yourself clear to what you are! The main reason that thread was pulled! I reported the fact you need to take peoples posts and change them to suite your mindset! If you act normal and just respond as you should it would still be there!