Grant had charisma???? Are you talking about Peter Grant? You do get excited easily don`t you? The board insisted that they would go for a manager with a proven track record, What track record has Roeder got? 1 good season at West Ham then got them relegated. He has not proven himself at this level either. I honestly hope he gets it right straight from the start on Sunday and prove me and the thousands of doubters wrong, but I`m not convinced.